Thumbsup & Thumbsdown <> GOOD or BAD

I've been watching YT videos and at many of them, in the comments section, I saw something like "Give me thumbs up if you think...". WTH?!?

Really! I don't have something personal with those YT users but seriously man... have a bit of decency in you. Of course, I didn't forget not many people are the same. These guys are ramentors ([email protected] + comment; I call them that). In the ol' days, when reading others opinion was, somehow, a pleasure for you as a reader. But now... "GIVE ME THUMBSUP IF...". Today, when I see these kind of comments, I observe Youtube staff are failing, day by day, in improving their great invention, instead of helping YT partners.

GOOD or BAD?


Oh, I've also saw at APH comments section: they're messed up with those ratings! There are many ramentors and trolmentors.

*EXCLUDING the karma in our forum.*


*UPDATE*

YES counts "No, they're a GOOD IDEA."
NO counts "Yes, they're a BAD IDEA."
Indifferent counts "Meh".

Sometimes it's okay on YT, because if it's a good comment than thumbs up will help more people see it.

I agree.

I'm indifferent, in relation to this, but I like the thumbs system. A lot. On Youtube.

I didn't saw any of these on youtube, only on APH (comments section is filled with that kind of comment).

Totally and officially the worst idea EVAR. You can't rate something with 2 options,it's like you either like it or not.
But the stars rating was way different,you can actually rate the video and show how much which is really important!

We are talking about comments,lol.

And yes, i think that the only thing that thumbs up/down attracts is thumb whores.

Its so dumb....

Yeah even about the comments. Dumb as hell

I can see how it could be informative forcertain users in certain conditions, but must of the time it is pointless, in my opinion.

The thumbs are good for hackers

"Thumbs up if you had no problem with this game, thumbs down if you did"

To many thumbs down and i would look through the game again