~!Check My Sigs Out!~ Feel free to Help/Criticize!

This topic is just for guidance and help/criticism because I like to make Photoshop (CS5) projects and siggs mostly, and I want help to make me better and comments will be appreciated. If you can, please give me a detailed description of what you think I should do and what I did wrong, also what I could do to improve.
~~ NO FIGHTING/FLAMING intended! I am just asking for help and yours is what I need :D ~~

Please tell me what you think about my siggy as of now and also this :-

http://i52.tinypic.com/nprnz6.jpg

One more thing, this is my solo request forum, so if you want me to do one just for a sample/guidance for me or you want me to do one for you, just give me the title, a render if you can, and a description of what you want on there.

(Example):-
Request
Title: MW2 Siggy
MW2 Render, or this:
http://planetrenders.net/renders/alb...2%20Render.png
I want a suitable background with C4Ds if possible and some nice effects
Also, put my name on the siggy where it will look good.
No border please

If you can supply any more details, please do so :D :cool2:

Looks really really really good, how long have you been working in PS? and welcome back...

The only thing I an say is the light seems a bit bright where you have all of the randomness, above his sword... I am sure there will be more

I also spy a slight error. The the left of the edge of his sword, there is a orangeish orb, and next to that there is a thin white line...

Willy

That was fast Will xD oh and thanks.......I think about 3-4 months now, I also saw your thread I thought it was pretty cool, I also could teach you some stuff if you like :D

And about the orange spot and line, yeah I know I messed up there, it was supposed to be a lighting effect, but it backfired :lol:

Those are actually pretty awesome!

Thanks Joonaqwe, any hints for me?

on the second one you added, I really don't like the Grid type thing you added over, it seems like either it needs to be added deeper into the image (layered down more), or just removed completely.

Willy

The "promasterz" one I don't like. It's way too busy, has no flow, and you randomly threw in a carbon fiber effect that doesn't match with anything.
However, your siggy I do like. A little awkward because it looks like you took the pencil tool to it for some reason, but other than that it looks really good.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WaltronX

This topic is just for guidance and help/criticism because I like to make Photoshop (CS5) projects and siggs mostly, and I want help to make me better and comments will be appreciated. If you can, please give me a detailed description of what you think I should do and what I did wrong, also what I could do to improve.
~~ NO FIGHTING/FLAMING intended! I am just asking for help and yours is what I need :D ~~

Please tell me what you think about my siggy as of now and also this :-

http://i52.tinypic.com/nprnz6.jpg

One more thing, this is my solo request forum, so if you want me to do one just for a sample/guidance for me or you want me to do one for you, just give me the title, a render if you can, and a description of what you want on there.

(Example):-
Request
Title: MW2 Siggy
MW2 Render, or this:
http://planetrenders.net/renders/alb...2%20Render.png
I want a suitable background with C4Ds if possible and some nice effects
Also, put my name on the siggy where it will look good.
No border please

If you can supply any more details, please do so :D :cool2:

---

The MW2 Siggy you call is just a render with a black background.

That is an example for a Sig Request Template mate

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LOLface

The MW2 Siggy you call is just a render with a black background.

---

Did you just really...? Obviously it's not a siggy!! It's a render!